Summary of Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination And Segregation Through Physical Design Of The Built Environment

Emir Talundzic on

In her article “Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination And Segregation Through Physical Design Of The Built Environment”, Sarah Schindler focuses on the issue of segregation through architectural design. Schindler divides her article in two parts. Part one discusses the theory of discrimination and segregation through architecture while part two discusses the application of this theory. This summary will highlight the major examples Schindler uses to describe the theory of discrimination and segregation through architecture as well as its application.

Since it is now unacceptable to segregate people openly, organizations and people have resorted to segregating people through architecture since it is much less obvious to the public. By designing things a certain way, such as the benches in a park, which are divided into sections, it can restrict certain types of people from wishing to use them. At first glance, the divided sections may seem practical because they allow people to sit among each other with space in between them. However, the divided sections of the bench may also serve as a deterrent for homeless people since they can no longer lay on the bench to sleep. (Schindler 1942).

Divided central park bench.

(Divided central park bench.)

To further support her theory, Schindler focuses on what the placement and availability of desirable items have on people, or as she calls it “features of the built environment that function to control human behavior or hinder access” (Schindler 1948). For example, Schindler uses the example of junk food and healthy food in a cafeteria. If the cafeteria wishes to offer the healthier options to the consumers, they will place them in areas that are easily accessible and visible. The options of junk food will still be available, but will be harder to reach and less visible in comparison to the healthier counterparts. (Schindler 1948). The point being made is that people will tend to do the things that are most convenient to them. Schindler ties this together by including the examination conducted by Lior Jacob Strahilevitz on exclusionary amenities. The idea is to segregate based on social class. By increasing the price of “exclusionary amenities” such as houses, it restricts the ability for poorer social classes to mix with the rich elite class. (Schindler 1949).

In part two of “Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination And Segregation Through Physical Design Of The Built Environment”, Schindler discusses the application of the theory of segregation through architecture. The first example used by Schindler are the bridges constructed by Robert Moses. Moses did not wish to mix the people of lower socioeconomic classes with the higher classes. In order to do this, Moses created the bridges that led to Jones’s Beach with a lower clearance, so that public transportation like buses would not be able to travel to the island. Moses did not wish to allow buses to travel to the island since public transportation is associated with people of lower socioeconomic classes, typically those of color. (Schindler 1953)

In addition to this, the placement of bus stops and construction of highways also plays a large role in architectural segregation. Many communities refuse to have bus stops placed near them since the bus stops would allow those who are poor to be able to travel to richer areas. Richer communities also influence the design and location of major highways, usually routing them through poorer areas in other to relocate those who lived there to other areas, effectively segregating them in specific areas away from the rich.

Schindler also uses examples of city design, such as the use of one way streets and lack of road signs. The use of one way streets may reduce traffic flow, but they also have been used to direct traffic flow away from particularly richer areas. When cities implement one way streets and remove road signs, it can be very difficult to navigate to and around the city in question. By making it difficult to travel to and from the city and confusing to navigate within the city, the chance that tourists and minorities will visit are very slim, leaving those of the higher class segregated from them.

Osborne Junction. Commonly known as Confusion Corner.

(Osborne Junction. Commonly known as Confusion Corner.)

Regardless of the reason provided for designing the infrastructure the way it is, the motive is always the same. Schindler identifies this modern day method of legal segregation and discrimination as architectural exclusion.

Bibliography 

Schindler, Sarah.“Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination And Segregation Through Physical Design Of The Built Environment.” Yale Law Journal 124.6 (2015): 1934-1972. Academic Search Complete. Web. 20 Nov. 2015.

1,102 thoughts on “Summary of Architectural Exclusion: Discrimination And Segregation Through Physical Design Of The Built Environment”

  4. Hi there, I do think your site might be having
    browser compatibility problems. Whenever I take a
    look at your web site in Safari, it looks fine however when opening in Internet Explorer, it’s got some overlapping issues.

    I merely wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!

    Besides that, fantastic site!

    My homepage – Spiwin77

    Reply

  6. The perceived worrth could be diminished if the provider basically presented a “paintable screen” with human and game elements rathher than a dealer addressing players at LeoVegas, for instance.

    my web-site :: git.basedzone.xyz

    Reply

  16. Характерным отличием конторы выступает консервативный и
    очень сдержанный дизайн сайта, мелбет регистрация который фактически заметно.

    Feel free to visit my blog: https://melbet-life16.xyz/

    Reply

  20. но при сложении бонусных средств рекомендуется
    принимать во внимание
    условия по вейджеру (отыгрышу), чтобы понимать,
    сколько раз.

    Also visit my site :: mostbet-1tb.top

    Reply

  25. I got this ѡebsite fｒom my ρal who tоld me about this web paɡe and now this time I am visiting this weeb site and
    rеading very informative cоntent here.

    Here is my blog post – Live Sex Sex Sex

    Reply

  29. I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or weblog posts
    in this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this web site.
    Studying this information So i am satisfied to show that I have a very just right uncanny feeling I discovered just what
    I needed. I most unquestionably will make certain to do not fail to remember this website and provides
    it a look on a relentless basis.

    my site: https://urushow.com/

    Reply

  32. сотни площадок соревнуются
    за интерес аудитории, постоянно увеличивая число аппаратов, улучшают
    качество сервиса, мостбет слоты а.

    Reply

  36. I just couldn’t leave your site before suggesting that I
    actually loved the usual information a person provide in your visitors?
    Is gonna be back incessantly in order to check up on new
    posts

    Also visit my web blog: POSTOTO787

    Reply

  41. Ԍoοd web site you’ve gott here.. It’s difficult to fibd high quuality writing like yous these days.
    I honestly appreciate peоple liike you! Tɑke care!!

    My blog post: XXX

    Reply

  43. With all due respect to Sarah Schindler, I think some of her statements are a bit far-fetched. She will put forward some things in architecture and design as discrimination, although in fact this is the usual logical order of things. For example, if the residents of some wealthy area really do travel by private cars, what is the need to build bus stops near their houses? For what, to disrupt the architectural ensemble of the building facade?
    Or, for example, I am interested in the architecture and design of exhibition stands. At large trade fairs, small and simple stands are usually located near the walls of the hall, and large exclusive exhibition stands are built in the center of the hall in the most passable places. Would Sarah Schindler also call this architectural discrimination?
    I think that this is not segregation or discrimination, you just get what you pay for. These are the realities of capitalist society, and no one here is trying to humiliate people, this is just how the world works.

    Reply

  49. অতিক্রম করার জন্য যোগ্যতাmarvelbet 777 login মার্ভেলবেট অবশ্যই আগের সপ্তাহে
    কমপক্ষে 5,000 ইয়েন হারিয়েছে.

    Reply

  50. Hi, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog site in Safari, it looks fine
    but when openinng in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted too give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, veryy good blog!

    My web site Loan for Day Laborers

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *