Summary of Schindler’s “Architectural Exclusion”

Sarah Schindler’s Architectural Exclusion examines an inconspicuous form of discrimination that may be more prevalent in our day to day lives than any other. This inequality goes unnoticed as it lies in regulation of the built environments we live in, but we simply see them as something as inconvenient as a one way road. As the essay points out later, one way streets may only exist headed in certain directions- directing the flow of traffic to keep the poorer side of town on their respective “side.” This is one of numerous forms of regulation Schindler analyzes pertaining to the restraints created by design.

Schindler argues that there is no “neutral design” in the environment. In layman’s terms, architectural functionality is dual- beyond that of simple aesthetics. Placement and design of anything from benches to bridges are intended to control the flow of people and how they interact with the environment. Neutrality is a middle ground, once taken away can only function to help some people and hurt others. This is where the idea of “traffic logic” comes into play, while an environment’s design can undermine certain groups of people, it also subconsciously reinforces negative behaviors between people i.e. what becomes discrimination.

Examples that are illustrated in the text range from gates to transit stops, to one way streets as aforementioned and parks and landscapes. Gates and public transport namely are described as what blatantly separates the poor and the rich, the people of color and the white people. Detroit built what was to be known as the Eight Mile Wall to separate an existing black community from a wealthy white community they were constructing nearby. A gate almost ten-feet-high in Hamden, Connecticut right in between a white suburb and the primarily black housing in New Haven. Schindler points out that if you fast forward thirty years and we have created a new, legal way to continue this blatant segregation- gated communities.

Public transport and transit stops are another “in your face” exclusion. People living in California to Georgia can attest to this as the essay denotes. People living in the suburbs around major cities like Atlanta and San Francisco vote to keep public transportation like MARTA out of their neighborhoods fearing that if they had a stop on the line it would be easy of access and bring more poor people and minorities to the area. Specifically they do not want those groups of people taking advantage of the jobs in the area and the more convenient amenities and ease of access one might find in the suburbs.

Just briefly in section two, Schindler mentions that local government partakes in architectural exclusion with blockades and traffic control. Looping roads and concrete barriers used to “lower crime rate” and ease the flow of traffic. This ties into another example of exclusion- highways and exits. Oftentimes exits are placed away from wealthier communities and highways used in hopes to displace black communities by running through them.

Schindler leaves us with the last example of residential parking permits. The idea behind them that only you and your friends have access to drive and park in these areas. They are not accessible by public transit and they prevent random people from wandering in and of the property. Courts will uphold these restrictive policies tying us back to the idea of why exclusionary regulation is so prominent and hard to undermine as most “do not believe” environment design intentionally separates.

Solid_white.svg

472 thoughts on “Summary of Schindler’s “Architectural Exclusion”

  • Join the FirstLine family as a brand ambassador! Share your passion for stylish, high-performance safety eyewear and help spread the word about our innovative products. Enjoy exclusive perks, connect with a community of like-minded individuals, and empower others to prioritize safety and style. Sign up today! ANSI Z87.1 Safety Glasses Campaign

  • Join the Bon Vivant Brand Ambassador Program to earn commissions, access exclusive perks, and support a veteran-owned mission. Led by Anthony B. Miles, a US Navy Trident Submarine Force Veteran, Bon Vivant blends style with safety, redefining eyewear for professionals and adventurers alike. Influencer Marketing Safety Goggles

  • The article is full of inspiration, thank you for sharing it! I used the Interactive AZ-140 questions to achieve a promotion and salary hike. Now, it’s free to all. Hope you all advance in your careers!

  • Your article provides a nuanced take on a subject that is both timely and compelling. I appreciate the depth of thought that has gone into presenting these ideas, which have encouraged me to see things from a new angle. It’s fascinating how such discussions can lead to broader revelations over time. Thank you for sharing this perspective. I think Ardian Jusufi shared something similar to this.

  • This is a well-crafted piece that raises several compelling points worth reflecting on. I find the way you’ve explored the topic to be both thoughtful and engaging. It’s always enlightening to encounter ideas that shift how I think about something. I look forward to seeing how conversations like this one evolve as new insights emerge. I shared a similar story hereand would love your feedback

  • Discover the ultimate collection of PNG sublimation files, SVG cut files, seamless patterns, fonts and procreate tools at Mastilo Designs. Perfect for small t-shirt business owners, POD shops, crafters and DTF printing shops. Shop now! Christian Faith Designs

  • Suchen Sie nach erschwinglichen elektrischen Transportmöglichkeiten? Schauen Sie sich unsere große Auswahl an Segway Ninebot GT2P-, Rolektro Trike- und Rolektro Quad-Modellen an, die Sie in bequemen Raten leasen oder kaufen können. Besuchen jetzt elektroroller-versand24.de! E-Roller mit langer Reichweite

  • Looking for a trusted health and safety consultant in Essex and London? Look no further than Terra Firma 360! Our team of experts provides comprehensive services to various industries, ensuring compliance and safety for your business. Contact us today for a customized solution today! Risk Assessment Consultant

  • I appreciate your article, it was so refreshing and insightful. Free PL-500 reliable test cram test questions—wishing everyone the best of luck on their exams!

  • Truly a captivating article, I’m thankful for your share! Thanks to the MS-700 latest soft simulations exam, I got promoted and earned a higher salary. Now, I’m giving it away for free today!

  • This is a fantastic read! Your explanation really cleared up some confusion I had. I’ll definitely be bookmarking this for future reference

    24kbet

  • Vind de perfecte accessoires voor elke stijl bij Florelle Accessoires. Ontdek onze elegante collectie oorbellen, kettingen, armbanden en ringen en geniet van gratis verzending vanaf € 50. Snelle levering binnen 1-3 dagen en veilige betalingen gegarandeerd. Winkel nu! Sterling zilveren sieraden

  • I’m really moved by this article, thanks for sharing! I used the CIS-CSM PDF cram exam to get promoted and get a pay raise. Now it’s free to all. I hope you all get promoted soon!

  • Fall in love with European fashion and home decor at Unique Love Brands! Shop our hand-picked selection of high-quality, unique products from Europe, all delivered with love to your doorstep. Discover the best European clothes and home decorating items online today. Eco-friendly home accessories

  • Telegram has truly transformed the way we communicate, but as we look deeper into the concepts of architectural exclusion discussed in this article, we see that exclusion is still prevalent in the urban landscape of Hong Kong. Many areas, especially the wealthier districts, design public spaces to keep lower-income groups out, which mirrors the concepts of urban segregation seen globally. It’s important that we address these issues if we want to create more inclusive environments.

  • Telegram groups in Hong Kong are a good example of how digital spaces can foster community and inclusion, yet, as highlighted in the article, physical spaces like parks and public housing often exclude marginalized populations. It’s ironic how technology facilitates inclusion while our built environment sometimes works in the opposite direction. We should rethink our city’s infrastructure to be more accessible to everyone, regardless of social class.

  • Telegram has become a vital tool for social movements, and it’s intriguing how technology allows marginalized communities to organize, similar to how architectural exclusion can isolate these groups physically. In Hong Kong, the design of certain malls or districts in Central and Tsim Sha Tsui often discourages public assembly or the free use of space. The challenge lies in addressing these urban designs that prioritize profit over inclusivity.

  • Telegram has become a platform where Hong Kong’s young generation discusses various social issues, but the physical spaces they occupy still reflect a kind of architectural exclusion, as discussed in the article. Whether it’s the restricted access to affordable housing or the exclusionary designs of public spaces in some areas, Hong Kong’s urban development needs to reconsider how it integrates people from all walks of life, especially those who are socially or economically marginalized.

  • Welcome to NukeTech, your one-stop shop for all thing’s electronics! We are a premier provider of high-quality electronic products catering to both personal and business needs. Our wide range of offerings includes phones, cameras, and more accessories. Shop now! USB-C fast chargers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *