Perspective


“Of all species of animals, the argument goes, humans are unique in that they occupy what Richard Shweder (1990:2) calls ‘intentional worlds‘. For the inhabitants of such a world, things do not exist ‘in themselves’, as indifferent objects, but only as they are given form or meaning within systems of mental representations. Thus to individuals who belong to different intentional worlds, the same objects in the same physical surroundings may mean quite different things” (Ingold, 41).

Overall Ingold’s main focus was describing how nature is a ‘cultural construction’ and the                   associations vary across cultures. When we observe things we see through a certain perspective         that has been ingrained in us by our culture and regional location. There is a Western perspective     in the United States, which makes us judge things according to what we believe to be the correct option.

 


 Listen to “The Wonders of the Rainbow Snake” 

Through their artwork, creation myths, and beliefs related to the rainbow serpent we will learn how snakes can be understood in a completely different way from our own culture. To aboriginals the rainbow serpent plays an integral part to their socio-religious ways of life.


For example, what are snakes to us? Some people have them as pets, we see them in zoos, and only   a small amount of churches conduct prayer adoration with snakes. We see Aztec traditions as being odd because how can they adore/venerate a snake? But who is to say what perspective is the right  perspective? Indigenous people could look at us and wonder why we have a god (snake) as a pet or locked away in a zoo.

Part I, Biology:

Believe it or not science has a lot to do with religion. For example, in Aztec religions during certain rituals animals are used as sacrifice. First we have to know how are animals classified? What characteristics are taken into account when classifying animals? This classification will be examined more closely in the next section. Many animals are venerated due to the characteristics they possess but in order to understand this some biological background over the animal is necessary. For reference we will look at the snake. A snake in religion is associated with life and rejuvenation, why? Because snakes are able to shed their skin. Their ability to see everything due to not blinking, associates them as excellent guards. Their ability to move rapidly due to their composition shows that they are very agile.

 


Listen to “Snake Cast”

Jon: They were first recognized for their wisdom.

Insha: And how is that?

Jon: Firstly, they seemed like the only animal that had mastered the art of eternal

youth, which for humans is an unattainable skill. But I think it must have something

to do with their focused, never blinking eyes. They have been watching everything,

recording everything their whole lives. Every so often, they shed they old skin and

emerge as youthful as before, ready to continue the recording process.

They never have to worry about missing something within the blink of an eye, yet

within the blink of our eyes, they can just disappear.


Part II, Folkbiology:

  • Across countries animals are referred to with names that someone might not understand. Let’s take the

    Python Snake in Zoo Atlanta.

    snake for example in Spanish it’s culebra, in Italian serpente, and so on. While some translations are easier to understand, the name does not always translate as easily. That is where science enters the picture by introducing the binomial nomenclature. Although it is not used in everyday language, the binomial nomenclature makes it easier for people to communicate across cultures. Common snakes such as snake make it easy for everyday people to communicate. However, the binomial nomenclature (2 names compiled of the first name indicating the genus and the second indicating the epithet, and are usually in Latin) allows scientists to communicate because they are able to refer to the same animal. While science allows us to communicate cross culturally because it has its own form of communication, it leaves behind meaning specific to a culture. “People’s actions on the natural world are surely conditioned in part by their ways of knowing and modeling it,” (Atran, 1).


Ex. Coatl→ snake

Quezalcoatl→ feathered serpent

Coatlique→ serpent skirt

 

These are the names for some most important deities in Aztec traditions. The names are specifically given depending on the characteristics they posses, so that they serve a descriptive purpose as well.

 

In science, it does not work like this. Names are given to animals so that someone in China could communicate with someone in the U.S. and be able to talk about the same animal.

 

Ex. Garter snake→ Thamnophis sirtalis

This name mainly serves to describe the appearance of the snake. So what is lost in translation is power or special qualities attributed to it.


Listen to “The Wonders of The Rainbow Snake”

Through their artwork, creation myths, and beliefs related to the rainbow serpent we will learn how snakes can be understood in a completely different way from our own culture. To aboriginals the rainbow serpent plays an integral part to their socio-religious ways of life.


Part III, Religions:

Ganesh statue in Carlos Museum at Emory University.

Religion is definitely associated with cultures. Certain regions have specific religions. Religion gives people a different perspective and view points on which they evaluate things.

For example, in a Christian setting a fish represents Jesus. Bread and wine is not just bread and wine, but the literal body and blood of Christ.

A snake in Aztec traditions represents way more than just an animal. It represents deities, gods, rebirth, the cycle of life, etc. As oppose to Western traditions where the snake might not be observed spiritually.

Views differ a lot based on the concept of animals. Where do animals fall? Should humans and animals be grouped together? Are they two completely different species? This is very hard because many see humans as superior. Superior because of the way they are able to communicate and interact. Humans have evolved and possess what is known as ‘extended consciousness’ in which “the individual has a clear sense of “me” and “you,” of “yesterday” and “tomorrow,” of “when I was a child” and “when I was a child” and “when I’m old”” (Fisher).  This ability to differentiate is what sets humans apart from animals. While many see humans as becoming less of an animal as time goes on, Amazonian people see it differently. “For Amazonian peoples, the original common condition of both humans and animals is not animalist but rather, humanity” (Vivieros de Castro, 465).

In Exchanging Perspectives: The Transformation of Objects into Subjects In Amerindian Ontologies, Vivieros de Castro discusses that it is not humans that have lost their animalistic qualities but rather animal retracting from their humanism. This is why animals are so important indigenous religions because they focus on the soul of the object instead. “The soul is formally identical in all species, it can only perceive the same things everywhere. The difference is given in the specificity of bodies” (Vivieros de Castro, 474). Therefore, animals are seen just as important as humans because they believe that they possess a similar soul that is simply instilled a different body. As you can see it is all just a matter as perspective. Some people see animals as inferior to humans while others consider them equally.

 

In cosmologies it is actually believed that objects and artifacts exited first and that they were responsible for the creation of the world. For example, in the Wakuénai cosmology the first humans and god are believed to be made of sacred flutes & trumpets. In the Tukano cosmology God existed first along with artifacts. In cosmologies “corporeal organization of species” usually exist which means that “each species [was] fabricated from the bodies and body parts of other natural species” (Santos-Granero, 6). This is a different kind of creation story then the one that people are use to. In this one the perspective of God created the world from nothing shifts to rather him shaping the world from objects that already existed.


As can be observed, the perspective one takes on things can have a huge effect on how they view things. The perspective each person has is unique and is based on things such as: location, morals, belief systems, etc.

 


Works Cited

Atran, Scott. “Folk Biology,” in MITECS: The MIT Encyclopedia of Cognitive Science.

 

“Common Garter Snake.” Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 13 Apr. 2017. Web. 24 Apr. 2017.

 

Crouch, Ceallsach, Gayle Kruger, Alyson Francis, and Remy Liverman. “The Wonders of the

Rainbow Snake.” Audio blog post. Rels 4700/6700. Soundcloud, 10 Apr. 2017. Web. 19 Apr. 2017.

 

DeMello, Margo. “Animals in Religion and Folklore” in Animals and Society: An Introduction

to Human-animal Studies. New York: Columbia University Press, 2012. 301-321.

 

Fisher, Helen. “2015 : WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT MACHINES THAT

THINK?” Edge.org. Edge, 01 Jan. 1970. Web. 24 Apr. 2017.

 

Ingold, Tim. “Hunting and Gathering as Ways of Perceiving the Environment,” in The Perception of the

Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill. New York:

Routledge, 2000. 40-60.

 

Ramirez, Nancy, Jonathan Harkey, and Insha Qari. “Snake Cast.” Audio blog post. Rels

4700/6700. Soundcloud, 10 Apr. 2017. Web. 22 Apr. 2017.

 

Santos-Granero, Fernando. “Introduction: Amerindian Constructional Views of the World” in

The Occult Life of Things: Native Amazonian Theories of Materiality and Personhood. Tucson: The University

of Arizona Pres, 2009. 3-29.

 

Vivieros de Castro, Eduardo. “Exchanging Perspectives: The Transformation of Objects into

Subjects in Amerindian Ontologies.” Common Knowledge. 10, no. 3. (2004) Durham:

Duke University Press. 463-484.

 

 

 

885 Responses

← Previous Page 18 of 18
  1. almalilly492 at |

    Hej! Jag tyckte att din artikel om perspektiv var riktigt intressant. Det är så sant hur mycket vårt synsätt påverkar hur vi uppfattar världen omkring oss. Jag håller verkligen med om att vi ibland behöver påminna oss själva om att se saker ur ett annat perspektiv för att kunna växa som människor. Tack för att du delade med dig av dina tankar!

    https://xn--mlaresdertlje-kfbf1z.se/

    Reply
  2. almalilly492 at |

    Vilket intressant perspektiv! Jag gillar verkligen hur du diskuterar olika vinklar på ämnet. Det är alltid uppfriskande att läsa andras tankar och reflektioner, speciellt när det handlar om ett sådant komplext ämne. Tack för att du delar med dig!

    https://www.xn--mlaretrosa-15a.se/

    Reply
  3. ezza em at |

    Vilket intressant perspektiv! Jag håller verkligen med om att våra erfarenheter påverkar hur vi ser på världen. Det är så spännande att tänka på hur samma situation kan tolkas helt olika beroende på våra egna bakgrunder och värderingar. Tack för en tankeväckande artikel!

    https://tamsimaleri.se/

    Reply
  4. ทางเข้าเล่น 123BET at |

    Thanks for sharing good information with us. i like your post And all you share with us is up to date.
    ทางเข้าเล่น 123BET

    Reply
  5. Perter at |

    I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work, its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. Thank You. Vist Pinoy Tambayan If You Want to Watch your favorite Filpino Dramas and shows.

    Reply
  6. kissasian at |

    Follow my site kissasian if you want to watch Up Asian country dramas without pop-ad

    Reply
  7. Mel at |

    I just had to share how impressed I am with the content you’ve created here! It’s clear that you’ve put a lot of thought and effort into it. I’ve been reading through other people’s experiences, and they all speak so highly of AI SEO Services for smarter digital marketing. It’s refreshing to see such genuine feedback. I’m excited to learn more and see how these insights can help us all grow. For anyone interested, check out this link for more: Content SEO.

    Reply
  8. daixie yy at |

    在留学的过程中,许多学生不仅需要面对繁重的学术任务,还可能要兼顾打工、社交以及生活的方方面面。在这种情况下,网课托管服务应运而生,并逐渐成为帮助留学生减轻学术负担、提升学业表现的重要手段。网课托管是一种帮助学生代为管理和完成在线课程的服务,涵盖从课程学习到作业提交、考试应对等一系列内容。通过网课代课,学生可以更好地平衡学业与生活,从而实现学术目标。

    Reply
  9. 실시간 바카라사이트 at |

    Each one of these small factors are made by utilizing quantity of basis attention.

    실시간 바카라사이트

    Reply
  10. 안전 슬롯사이트 at |

    It’s similarly a fantastic write-up i usually certainly appreciated analyzing.

    안전 슬롯사이트

    Reply
  11. 토토사이트 추천 at |

    This method is actually aesthetically truly the most suitable.

    토토사이트 추천

    Reply
  12. 안전한 카지노사이트 at |

    It’s a wonderful platform for personal growth.

    안전한 카지노사이트

    Reply
  13. 파워볼실시간 at |

    Great article Lot’s of information to Read

    파워볼실시간

    Reply
  14. 안전한 카지노사이트 at |

    I gotta most loved this site it appears to be exceptionally useful.

    안전한 카지노사이트

    Reply
  15. Tanmay Desai at |

    A highly beneficial blog! You’ve nailed it. Being an authority on the topic, I can appreciate the dedication behind this. Aarti Kunj Bihari Ki PDF

    Reply
  16. Manish Sethi at |

    It’s rare to come across such a helpful blog. Truly exceptional. As an expert, I admire your thorough approach. Sai Baba Aarti PDF

    Reply
  17. Ravi Kumar at |

    This is one of the most detailed blogs I’ve come across. Very well done! As someone experienced in this field, I respect your expertise. DURGA AARTI PDF

    Reply
  18. Kunal Sharma at |

    Your blog is one of the most insightful ones out there. Excellent work! As a subject expert, I understand and value your effort. Brihaspati Chalisa PDF

    Reply
  19. Pulkit Agarwal at |

    A fantastic read and one of the most beneficial blogs on the subject! I applaud your efforts as an expert in the field. Brahma Chalisa PDF

    Reply

Leave a Reply to آسرون Click here to cancel reply.

Skip to toolbar