Why My Presentation Sucked: Part 2

A couple of weeks ago I posted part one of this series. You might want to check that out if you’d like to read my conference proposal – or don’t and just jump in here. All you really need to know is that my presentation concerned competing personal philosophies and how we live with these as educators. Spoiler Alert: You also might want to know that this post is really about the importance of failure. 

Conference Fantasies and Realities

Now for the thrilling conclusion of Why My Presentation Sucked! So I arrived at my conference to pouring rain and, of course, a complete lack of umbrella. Luckily I had a bag of donation clothes in my backseat and found a trenchcoat. A mix of bad and good omens. As I walked the half mile (!) from the parking lot to the conference center I ran through my presentation, envisioning myself spurring deeeeeep, meaningful conversations among the session attendees with my wit, emotional rawness, and a bodacious visual presentation.

Of course, conference presentation fantasies don’t ever match reality. Here’s what really happened: I walked into a room of 5 audience members. One of them was the facilitator and the other was a fellow presenter. Was this a tiny conference? Did these folks have a burning interest in my topic – or were they just there for the other dude? I went first. Although my audience appeared rapt and nodded their heads at several points I could tell that they weren’t buying my message. I invited questions and comments during my talk but no one engaged me. I began to talk faster. I gave a million examples. I talked about my probably-too-esoteric slide image choices and how they illustrated my points. I walked around a lot, smiled, grimaced, gesticulated – a grand performance. When I was finished (20 minutes early) I opened the floor up to discussion: “How do competing personal philosophies affect your teaching and living in education”? Only one taker. She talked about moving from a traditional highly structured high school to one that allows students much greater personal freedom. Although I know nothing about K-12 I immediately went into faculty development mode, leaned over the desk, and let her tell her story. The presentation became a conversation between us about the joys and despairs of structural constraints. The rest of the room was blank faced. I ended my presentation and the next presenter shot me a squinty eyed look. He began his part, introducing himself as a philosophy professor. I felt like a baby.

Fail: Starbucks Coffee sign with

Basically, my presentation…

Why My Presentation Failed

After mulling over my conference experience I concluded that my presentation failed because: 

  • I didn’t know my audience: This was my first time at this particular conference and my audience (other than the facilitator and other presenter) were K-12 folks. Thus, my examples and struggles were aimed at an entirely different group of educators.
  • I didn’t create an “active” presentation: Every presentation I’ve done in the past has involved a lot of audience work – small readings, discussions, short writing exercises. In this way the audience gets a few minutes to make a personal connection to the material. I always get a hugely positive response when I run sessions this way. However, this time I took a chance and did a narrative, experience-based presentation. 

So, overall, I failed because I took a chance on a new presentation type at an unknown conference. But was my failure a bad thing? I argue no. Although I experienced some temporary personal embarrassment my experience as both a student and an educator suggest that failure is more educative than success. After all, would I have taken two weeks to consider and write about this experience if I had succeeded? Probably not. Instead my failure spurred me to reflect deeply on my experience. I’ve seen this same pattern in my own students again and again (with a lot of support, of course). So if you accept my premise that failure is good, how can you support failure in your own classroom?

Supporting Failure in the Classroom

Failure is an integral part of student growth in any college classroom. After all, aren’t questions and mistakes more instructive than correct answers? Doesn’t struggle create more resilient, questioning students? There are many strategies that you can use to support student failure including:

  • Setting a failure-friendly tone early in a course. Try including a short narrative in your syllabus that addresses the high likelihood of struggle in your course. Offer suggestions to live with this struggle. Have students write about past failures in class and share these. Share your own failures with your class. Setting a failure-friendly tone creates a vulnerable space for rigorous, personally-rewarding work.
  • Allowing students to struggle with low-stakes, formative assessments. Often big failures on exams, presentations, or other heavily-weighted assignments can overwhelm students. Instead, consider the thousand little cuts method by building ungraded opportunities for practice (and failure) into your course. Allow students to practice failing.
  • Providing students with targeted feedback and support after a failure. Failure-friendly classes won’t succeed without significant feedback and support. Talk with your entire class about general patterns of performance after minor and major assignments. Offer to meet with your students one-on-one after a big fail. Put your students in groups at the beginning of the semester to spread out the failure support net. 
  • Framing coursework as process-oriented rather than outcomes-oriented. Most undergraduates at GSU come from a high-stakes, assessment-oriented K-12 environment. Unsurprisingly, this educational philosophy rewards getting it “right” the first time. Obviously his educational approach isn’t failure friendly.  How could you help your students think about and struggle with a more process-oriented, iterative approach to thinking and performance in your course? 
  • Framing failure as data rather than a catastrophic defeat. Take a note from the natural sciences and help your students see failures as iterative self-experiments. Some instruction to your students on discipline-specific thought would be fantastic here. How do researchers in your area frame research “failures”?
  • Building failure into the curriculum. Allowing your entire class to fail at a particular task (or tasks) can be a powerful pedagogical strategy. How could you provide your students with planned opportunities to fail? For instance, are there particular content areas that all (or most) students struggle with without significant support or resources? After failure, how could you debrief students on the process? What type of follow-up assignment or activity do you need to create to follow up on the failure? How do you need to support this activity?
  • Modeling failure for your students. This one can be tough on many professors. We’re used to acting the part of the all-seeing, all-knowing experts in class – and our students usually buy this superhuman act to the detriment of the student-professor relationship. So, along with building failure into the curriculum think about how you could model failure to your students. And by model I don’t mean creating artificial one-act failure plays that you perform for the class. Instead, I’m referring to those frequent times in class when you don’t know something or you don’t know how to handle a situation. How could you struggle, fail, struggle, succeed, and then struggle again in front of your class? 
About

Bing

Tagged with:
Posted in #trending
31 comments on “Why My Presentation Sucked: Part 2
  1. Research Writing Services says:

    The writers of all the Online Essay Writing Service tasks have to have in-depth knowledge of the particular topics they wish to write on, and also have to be passionate about Custom Writing Services.
    https://www.meldaresearch.com/

  2. Xo jeain Pe says:

    Such a piece of important information. Keep it up. china b2b marketplace

  3. Warlocket says:

    Very informative and useful article for beginners! TalktoSonic Customer Survey

  4. GraveNinja says:

    Thank you so much for helping with this wonderful article. https://www.myaarpmedicare.vip/

  5. Clinica Estetica Sevilla says:

    En nuestra Clinica estetica sevilla somos especialistas en tratamientos médicos estéticos avanzados como el injerto capilar con una unidad de recuperación del cabello especializada.

  6. alaskasworld says:

    Thanks for the update and quick reply. I’ll be sure to keep an eye on this thread. Looking for the same issue. Bumped into your thread. Thanks for creating it. Looking forward for solution.
    https://www.alaskasworld.me/

  7. ximatan says:

    Today, we are in the digital era. Scores of people are getting access to the internet by the minute. Thus, there is a need to uniquely identify each device that is a member of the internet. An IP address is something that helps with the same. 192.168.ol

  8. Gvinajamesh says:

    Thank you so much for helping with this wonderful article.https://myaarpmedicare.link/

  9. Marks4sure says:

    I am a passionate for IT Certification exams dumps. I provide latest dumps questions answers. Our success rates in the past two years have been absolutely impressive, thanks to our happy customers who are now able to proper their careers in the fast lane. Marks4sure is the number one choice among IT professionals. Microsoft is the industry leader in information technology, and getting certified by them is a guaranteed way to succeed with IT careers. We help you do exactly that with our high quality Microsoft Exam Questions and Practice dumps materials.

  10. Nathan says:

    Thanks for sharing the information.

    https://www.facetimeapp.net/

  11. Inamena says:

    Thanks for the update and quick reply. I’ll be sure to keep an eye on this thread. https://10reviews.com.au/

  12. faona says:

    I failed because I took a chance on a new presentation type at an unknown conference. But I think that failure is not a bad thing https://getonlinesurveys.com/

  13. emankhan says:

    very nice post please visit buyfbpagelikes.com

  14. 메이저토토사이트 says:

    Your opinion helped a lot. You are really great. Please keep a lot of good articles in the future. 메이저토토사이트 Thanks a lot.

  15. ahtisham734 says:

    We are an online writing company established to help students from all over the world. We aim at making college life more enjoyable for students, which is why we are always available for students’ help. We provide services in writing assignment and proofreading so that students can submit their assignments on time. These assignments are plagiarism free.
    Buy Essay Custom

  16. ahtisham734 says:

    We are an online writing company established to help students from all over the world. We aim at making college life more enjoyable for students, which is why we are always available for students’ help. We provide services in writing assignment and proofreading so that students can submit their assignments on time. These assignments are plagiarism free.
    Write My Essay

  17. Zaeem Arif says:

    very nice post please check https://onlinemahjong247.com for more games

  18. Marcin says:

    I have read your text and the previous one that you prepared for the conference. Both are fantastic. Congratulations

    naked gilrs

  19. Semin734 says:

    The jackets that we sell are replicas of the coats worn by top television celebrities because it is a growing trend to copy them when it comes to fashion. These celebrities have really become the trendsetters. This leisure was hitherto in reach of only the rich and the rest could only dream about it. But now these jackets are available for all people who want to buy them because of our affordable prices. So we welcome you to come and buy celebrity jackets of excellent quality and know more about us and our products!
    Shearling Jackets Coats

  20. John says:

    Thanks for this great post, i find it very interesting and very well thought out and put together. I look forward to reading your work in the future.
    Emergency Locksmith Waldorf MD

  21. Kinda Glarrison says:

    I admire what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well.
    Vehicle Lockout Waldorf MD

  22. kalvinjohn says:

    These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future..
    CAT5 and CAT6 Wiring Services in Zephyrhills FL

  23. Arnold Miler says:

    With over ten years of experience servicing clients nationally, we feel we are the Top Digital Marketing Company. We use digital platforms to share your story and bind your brand to clients, boosting your company and assisting you in reaching your full online potential.

  24. Rosie says:

    Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading.
    Delivery Services in Fairfax VA

  25. Rosie says:

    Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.
    Junk Removal Services in Fairfax VA

  26. Rosie says:

    Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.
    commercial moving services Fairfax VA

  27. 바카라사이트 says:

    I will bookmark this site and come to it from time to time. Your writing has been of great help to me.바카라사이트

  28. clair filip says:

    It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.
    Carpet Sanitizing Severna Park MD

  29. Leading Digital Marketing Services Company in New Jersey says:

    We, CMT Direct, can help you get more LEADS, traffic, and revenue with the right strategy. Leading Digital Marketing Services Company in New Jersey.
    ac

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Skip to toolbar