Blog 3 – ACA – March 20

Is the devil we know as US healthcare worse than the devil we do not know as US healthcare under the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA)? Also, is the ACA intimately tied to whether or not to extend unemployment insurance benefits?

In her book Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making, Deborah Stone reviews different models of persuasion. Specifically, Stone observes that persuasion in the polis is divided into business and government persuasion. Stone’s description of business persuasion appears to be overtly powerful in that it: is dominated by capitalism, sponsors and manipulates public perception of scientific research, uses education materials and programs to develop support for policy positions, and owns and uses mass media to influence public opinion. Her description of government persuasion appears to be covertly powerful in that: citizens’ behaviors are influenced by lower-level bureaucrats using benefits and punishments, some policy purposefully attempts to shape citizens’ characters, newsworthy information can be slanted, information withheld, or publication forbidden. In light of the two types of persuasion Stone discusses, what we know with regard to the ACA and extending unemployment insurance benefits is identified through the lens of who is asking what question of whom, and when.

There are few areas regarding the US healthcare system and health insurance that which both business and government seem to agree. The US is identified as being the only developed nation to not have a universal health care system; however, the US government does spend more than double that of other developed countries on this issue. The most obvious differences between these other developed countries and the US regarding healthcare provision are demonstrated in the video, Sick Around the World. Those differences are discussed as being integral parts of universal healthcare: medical providers must charge standard prices to keep cost down; by law, everyone must buy health insurance, through an employer or community plan, for which a patient cannot be turned down for a pre-existing illness; insurance for the poor is subsidized; and perhaps the largest primary difference – in a universal health care system, insurance companies are restricted from making a profit on basic medical care.

Why does the debate on the US healthcare system matter now? In her Class Blog, Dr. Margaret Palmiter makes the observation that “unemployment and health care and poverty are totally and completely entwined.” This idea is demonstrated in the video, Sick Around America. The link between these concepts is shown to be the declining economy leading to high unemployment, whereby more people end up in poverty, with one result being lost health insurance. In the US, health insurance is a private system that has failed to provide coverage for 46 million people, leaves millions more underinsured due to rising insurance costs, exposes many to being medical bankruptcy risks, and in some cases, can lead to death. Extending health care coverage to those without is the idea behind many of the reforms established by the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. The primary goals of the ACA are to increase quality and affordability of health insurance. Lowering the rate of those uninsured is to be achieved by enlarging public and private insurance coverage and reducing the costs of healthcare for individuals and the government.

Is the ACA changing the health insurance situations for Americans? The answer is both yes and no because, as Deborah Stone observes, for everything that is included, something else is excluded. Those remaining uninsured are illegal immigrants ineligible for insurance subsidies and Medicaid. Also remaining uninsured are citizens not enrolled in Medicaid despite being eligible, citizens not otherwise covered and opting to pay the annual penalty, and citizens whose insurance coverage would cost more than 8% of household income and are exempt from paying the annual penalty. Additionally, remaining uninsured are poor minorities and single-mother citizens who live in one of 26 states, the ones with the most uninsured, opting out of the Medicaid expansion and who qualify for neither existing Medicaid coverage or subsidized coverage through the states’ insurance exchanges. Depending on the state of residence, this description includes citizens similar to those depicted in Jason DeParle’s book American Dream. The insured include children and dependents, as portrayed in Sick Around America, who can now remain on their parents’ plans until their 26th birthday. Others described in the video can now have access to health insurance as well, such as the man with the pre-existing condition, the woman needing a second surgery, and the Massachusetts family who could not afford the previously too-high premium rates. As observed in The Mental Anguish of the Long-term Unemployed article, many long-term unemployed can qualify for Medicaid or heavily subsidized health insurance that would include coverage for the comorbid conditions of declining mental health and addiction.

How are the ACA and extending unemployment insurance benefits tied together? The primary answer is well described in a comment to the article Should We Extend Unemployment Insurance – And Cut the Minimum Wage. As one reader comments: “They’re playing games with 2 million american lives over a childish tantrum rooted in obamacare [ACA]. So we’re all losing shelter, our vehicles (forget getting a job more than walking distance from your house now), and going on welfare and foodstamps because Republican children are throwing a very old tantrum.” This situation is also observable in Tampa, Florida where a Republican narrowly won a special congressional election that which prompted the Republicans to espouse that this showed that Obamacare would cost the Democrats the mid-term elections. However, these mid-term elections highlight the risks of congressmen voting against a government program extension of unemployment insurance benefits in states where the jobless rate is particularly high, such as Ohio and Illinois. Having lost on the issue of the ACA, the Republicans are using the possibility of not extending unemployment insurance benefits as a revenge tactic. This observation is further encapsulated in the article Jobless Benefits – The GOP’s Search for an Exit.

For many Americans, such as young adults and the long-term unemployed, healthcare stories are changing as access to health insurance becomes available. Is the existence of the ACA lowering the rate of the uninsured? The latest information regarding the ACA comes from a March 2014, Gallup-Healthways Well-Being survey. Their finding suggests that the uninsured rate has dropped by 2.8 % primarily among households making less than $36,000 per year.

22,297 thoughts on “Blog 3 – ACA – March 20

  1. How To Become a Naturopathic Doctor is designed to encourage new interest in the field
    of Naturopathic Medicine. You will find interest introduction to various disciplines
    within the field of Naturopathic Medicine as well as some historical context regarding
    how this branch of medicine became the “alternative” Medicine. Acupuncture, Homeopathy,
    and Chinese medicine introductions are found here as well. Medical Director Dr. Maggie
    Garvin also discusses her Naturopathic practice on the site. Submit your contact
    information if you are a Naturopath willing to share your story about your journey to
    becoming a ND. If you are considering the field, submit your contact information to
    learn more about the various educational options available in North America.


  2. Cvlogy est un site de recrutement en ligne et l’un des leaders des sites de recherche d’emploi et de création de CV au Maroc. Cvlogy propose aux chercheurs d’emploi plusieurs services: évaluation de CV, création de CV, offres d’emploi, accopagnement, bases de contacts entreprises..

    Site de recrutement

  3. Have fun Atari Breakout! The long-awaited sequel to the classic Chaos Faction 2! Battle your way through 15 new campaign levels with new weapons, characters, moves, and more explosions than you can shake a stick of dynamite at. Super Mechs, a breathtaking turn-based strategy game, gives you a unique chance to create an invincible super robot!

  4. I was very pleased to find this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post. Website Information Webpage

  5. Hello Queen of Escorts one of the biggest platform in the field of Escorts in Dubai, we are specialist to provide Indian Escorts in Dubai, call girls in Dubai, Arab and international Escorts in Dubai we says you welcome to our website and for our services.

    Indian Escorts in Dubai

  6. Hello Queen of Escorts one of the biggest platform in the field of Escorts in Dubai, we are specialist to provide Indian Escorts in Dubai, call girls in Dubai, Arab and international Escorts in Dubai we says you welcome to our website and for our services.

    Indian Escorts in Dubai

  7. Waist Training Corset helps you achieve the hourglass figure you have always
    dreamed of with the added pizzazz of an animal print.
    Look sexy and feel sexy as you watch the inches melt away.
    Being constructed in this way creates compression and stimulates perspiration,
    which is what helps Waist Training Corset perform its magic in your midsection.
    This garment’s quality made construction creates increased thermal activity,
    which simply means you will see results much quicker than you may have imagined.
    The lining is made of cotton and spandex and the outer layer is also contains 100
    latex along with a silky animal print that makes your figure pop. This beautiful
    garment’s inner layer is constructed of 100 percent latex rubber.

    Waist Training

  8. Description: Black Lives Matter is a group of people from all walks
    of life and all races coming together to fight the ever growing dangers
    of the terrorist organization called the Black Lives Matter


  9. We specialize in helping ordinary people reach extraordinary business goals
    Specifically, we develop behavioral programs, policies and procedures necessary
    to start organizations such as the residential group home (adult and children),
    medical and non-medical home care and staffing agencies, adult day programs,
    companion care agencies, transportation companies.

    group home help

  10. Viral media bay is a website with the essential knowledge in how to build a
    website and get it done first by seo and social media with a viral edge.
    The articles comes out at least 4 times a month ,also starting to make a
    lot of viral articles Buzzfeed,Viralnova style!!On the viral side you
    as a subscriber can make your own articles and get them published at
    the site as well :)Visit us and see for your self.

    viral media

  11. We can all agree that the US healthcare system and health insurance were wanting and this is why the government decided to come up with Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA). We hope that this plan we will be far much better than the previous one. Oral Presentation Writing Help

  12. We assist with starting, managing and growing adult day programs,
    homes & companion care, personal care homes, and transportation
    companies in all states. Our services also extends into the community
    mental health, rehabilitation and nursing home sectors. Hence,
    our business model offers an impeccable insight and specialized
    set of skills for these niches

    home care company

  13. Vindicta Digital – An award winning agency are based in both London and Belfast.
    Their skilled team members specialise in all things digital.
    Web Design, Branding, SEO, Marketing and more.

    Web Design Belfast

  14. somos una empresa que vende misotrol en Chile y también misotrol en Santiago,
    ya que es un medicamento de difícil acceso, porque que en las farmacias es
    complicado de conseguir. Muchas veces tampoco queremos que nuestros vecinos
    o familiares se enteren de nuestro estado por lo que
    la mejor manera de ocultarlo es comprarlo por internet,
    ya que comprar misotrol en Santiago es más complicado,
    es por esto que vendo misotrol sellado.

    Sitio Oficial Misotrol Chile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *