Blog 2 – March 3

The intersection of race, gender and class: How did reading DeParle change your perception of the ability of social policy to combat poverty? In thinking about Stone’s definition of the goal of liberty and the problem of equality, describe how DeParle’s book discusses the liberty-welfare trade off. Do you think DeParle believe’s there is a trade off?

Changing My Perception

Reading DeParle did not change my perception that social policy can only somewhat assist in combating poverty. DeParle summarizes the differing social policies and approaches to poverty of multiple political administrations. Although a variety of social policies and strategies are tried in attempts to improve poverty, arguably the situation of poverty in this country is not substantially diminished. The effort to combat poverty is equally as important as the ways and means. If the condition of poverty is not essentially changing, then the way effort is used, and the means by which it is applied, makes the effort less valuable. While social policy is a valuable tool in assisting to combat poverty, there are a few important factors largely unaddressed by DeParle and our society: the prevalent drug culture in areas of poverty, men in poverty, and welfare recipients missing as voices in the political process.

DeParle’s Description of the Liberty-Welfare Tradeoff

By having a welfare system based upon not providing clear pathways to leave, such as through education and improved job skills, people naturally revert to using the welfare resource system as a means for being sustained. Welfare recipients are survivors in a harsh environment where personal strength and perseverance, community, and survival education are the primary quality of life factors. DeParle observes that Jewell worked for the post office and continued to receive her full welfare and food stamps. In her words “money was just coming in from everywhere” (DeParle, p. 158) and a desire for life to be different is not expressed. That scholastic education is not portrayed to those who are impoverished as an important tool for advancement out of poverty explains why Jewell failed a reading test for possible work placement. The value of having reading skills is considered to be low. At this point, Jewell is not shown to express a desire for a different life style that might not include welfare and is not seeking tools to change her situation. Jewell demonstrates a willingness to work at various low-paying jobs such as office cleaning and telemarketing. Additionally, she willingly provides child caregiving services for her housemates that do work. By mid-point in his book, the trade off DeParle seems to describe is that those who are impoverished receive the most basic of food, shelter, medical, and education needs in order to maintain them as a domestic source of low cost labor.

Does Deparle Believe There is a Tradeoff

Yes in the sense that Stone observes that to be dependent on others for welfare means being subject to their control. In the survival impressions from DeParle’s case studies, people will do what they need to do to survive. Under current policy, survival means taking advantage of the welfare system. Survival is not dependent on education or job advancement; conversely, these are risks. In this respect the welfare system is set up to not advance people out. Perpetuating reliance on the welfare system could be considered an infringement on liberty, having a real choice free of the possibility of hurting their survival chances.


 No in the sense that Stone observes that complete self-sufficiency is an illusory ideal and dependence on others is inevitable-but help from others enhances liberty. As chronicled by DeParle, survival is dependent upon available resources. The resources identified by welfare recipients are as support provided by people and money from welfare checks, jobs, and family and friends. Money from welfare and jobs are balanced by the state but assistance from family and friends can favor the recipient and enhance liberty. Because those on welfare support each other, all who participate are positively affected, for example: by exchanging TANF and SNAP benefits, transportation, and childcare services.


DeParle, J. (2004). American Dream. New York, New York: Viking Penguin.

Stone, D. (2012). Policy paradox. New York, New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.

9,251 thoughts on “Blog 2 – March 3

  1. bitdefender central – It provides best protection for all of your devices like Windows, Mac OS, iOS and Android. Bitdefender Central Antivirus is a great performer when it comes to secure your devices from malware attacks and cyber threat. This works in two dimension like it finds and destroy malware at same time. Bitdefender Central will be a good recommendation because of its User-friendly feature at low price. It protects your computer from inside and outside threats.

  2. To introduce Office, have a go at marking in straightforwardly to the Office 365 Software page. Select the language and bit-form you need (PC clients can pick between 32-bit and 64-bit), and after that snap Install. See Steps 2 and 3 on the PC or Mac tabs above to assist you with the remainder of the introduce procedure.Visit

  3. – Mcafee provide complete range of security for your software and devices. Mcafee is the most simplest and effective way to protect your data and devices from Cyber threats.Mcafee scans malware for your device and provide security solution recommendation. It also scans your browser history seamlessly. You can customize how often you want your computer to be scanned with Mcafee.

  4. I’m truly getting a charge out of the structure and design of your site. Your style is extremely extraordinary in contrast with the different people I have perused stuff from. I want to introduce my site if you take interest in marketing then visit my site.I hope you like it.

  5. Hi, Great Post! Needcdrreport started this service to provide genuine CDR writing help to these needful engineers. If any Engineering students Need CDR writing Help for college student then you have simply contact our expert team we have to provide the best CDR writing help. Our expert is available 24*7.

  6. Texasbet365 adalah situs permainan judi bola terbaik yang sanggup membayar kemenangan member dan mempunyai rasa tanggung jawab atas bettingan member
    Selalu daftar menggunakan link alternatif resmi texasbet365 dapat membuat anda bermain lebih hoky dan tenang pasti ny Pingback: Bola88

  7. Norton Setup and Instal Process – For both PC and mobile users. Highly popular among the PC users, the Norton antivirus software has been eliminating malware, viruses and other kinds of online and offline threats from affecting the performance of a computer for years. , being a security solution providing company has created ..

  8. Norton Setup and Instal Process – For both PC and mobile users. Highly popular among the PC users, the Norton antivirus software has been eliminating malware, viruses and other kinds of online and offline threats from affecting the performance of a computer for years. , being a security solution providing company has created ..

  9. Very knowledgeable Post…Thanks
    Tech to Review is the best platform for the latest technical news like smartphones, pcs, speakers, etc. It provides the latest offers related to laptop, smartphones, PC, speakers and so on, which help you to get the best fit product. Visit here:

  10. We are here to make your academic life easy by providing you top-notch online essay writing service UK. With more than a decade’s experience, we have gained the status of the most trusted report writing service UK. We cater to the students in all UK experts’ cities including London, Bristol, Manchester, Liverpool, Glasgow, Birmingham, etc. As different UK universities have different requirements regarding online thesis writing service UK, we provide customized help with online assignment writing service UK So, get started with us and achieve academic success.

  11. Being isolated from this market, I have worked as independent escort worker there are lots of things to be considered for my how can I emerge myself into this market that’s why I had chosen the path of independent escort agency and worked hard, finally I made my own agency under which several kinds of independent Russian Escorts ladies have been working with me.
    Delhi Russian Escorts

  12. Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!
    data science course

  13. Great Article! It very Informative and useful keep sharing like that, This is a great post. I check your blogs regularly but after reading this blog and I’m inspired. I’m Definitely sharing this blog with my friends! Keep inspiring like that!
    Read Also:-
    Phone Cleaner

  14. Clipping path is essential for any type of product images. Clipping Path Service can provide the desired product with a high-end view that will help you attract both organic customers and customers who pay to add. Make a clipping path for the growth of your business and show your customers what you have! best clipping path service product images

  15. If you still have issue while depositing or withdrawing cryptocurrency from Bittrex, even if you fail to create or login to your Bittrex account, just feel free to get in touch with Bittrex Customer Support services for technical assistance with issues related to Bittrex wallet.

    bittrex support

  16. Hi I’m Aiden, If you are planning to visit Newark, In every flight ticket booking that you do with us is discounted. Our main aim is to provide the flight reservations at the cheapest price; every flight price is reduced to make it budget-friendly.To book Cheap Flights From Los Angeles To Newark, You can make a call on Airlines Reservation Number +1 (877) 728 8804 to get the best deals.Also buy Cheap Airline Tickets Online at on Call.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *