Letting Go: Gamification, Control, and User Perceptions of Design

Recently, I was reading some literature on gamification and came across an interesting  idea: Namely, that even if we create a gamified lesson or course we can’t force students to play and enjoy the end product as a game. Students could, instead, view your intricately designed experience as a means to an end or as a ridiculous drudge. Students might also use your gamified course in unexpected ways. For instance, what if some students add rules to your gamified course unbeknownst to you? What if your course becomes a game within a game? Does this matter outside of the official rules?

If we think about this in a larger sense end-users are going to use, remix, and subvert designed products in a million different ways. This happens to all of us on a daily basis. For instance, have you ever used a shoe as a hammer? Eaten leftovers from a restaurant? Faux-texted to avoid conversation? These are all examples of end-users (probably you!) using products in novel ways or in contexts alien to their origins.

This design subversion also includes both online and face to face formal learning experiences. For instance, if you’ve ever taught in a physical classroom you know that students use this space for a variety of activities outside of those officially designated by the university from socializing to grooming to sleeping. In essence, students have changed the rules of the game named classroom and continue to evolve these rules for better or worse.

Let’s briefly think about online course design now. How can we measure and control student perceptions of and, ultimately, use of our course designs given end-users’ penchant to upend official uses? In my opinion we can’t. Even if you set up the most linear, locked down, automated online course possible some students will find a way to circumvent your intentions. This subversion isn’t going to come in the form of students hacking into course files – instead, you might find yourself deluged with emails from students asking for extra time on quizzes or complaining that you don’t give enough feedback. In other words students are struggling to rewrite the rules of linearity,  structure, and depersonalization. What do you do here? I admit that this type of surreptitious perversion can be frustrating – but, in my case, I’m not sure that I’d really want it any other way. After all this struggle, this constant re-gamification by students demonstrates a certain type of strategic, creative approach to bounded experiences. And let me put a huge caveat here: I’m not saying that students are always (or even often) right in their thinking in “gaming” us but I think that they sometimes are. How can we use these little moments of brilliance to improve our designs?

So the next time that you feel a lesson or course slipping from your control ask yourself: Should you scramble to enforce the official rules or should you bend them a bit (or a lot!) to create a new game?



Posted in #trending
114 comments on “Letting Go: Gamification, Control, and User Perceptions of Design
  1. Johns Mak says:

    Are you looking for stylish names and nicknames for your garena free fire game ?

    Then must check most popular website that provides stylish name for free fire – freefirestylishname.com

  2. Benjamin Clerk says:

    Need an embroidery digitizer at a cheap price, we are here for you.digiembroidey provides the best quality embroidery digitizing at a cheap price par stich.

  3. kavuquj678 says:

    This post will update your information about Kroger SecureWEB Login, steps for secure web login Kroger, GreatPeople.me Kroger SecureWEB Login, Kroger Pay Stub, and Kroger Associate Benefits portals.

    secure web.Kroger

  4. Emma Moore says:

    Hello. Thanks a lot for sharing this article. I want to present you an article https://primeessays.com/answers-questions-homework-online.html I am a beginner writer and want to get feedback. Thanks beforehand.

  5. allphysicalguide says:

    Hello guys ! If u want to know more about Best Silk Hair Wraps for Your Natural Hair
    Then click on this link

  6. technicalsandy says:

    Hello guys ! Do you want to know how to create Blog to earn money then visit this site

  7. jurnalisa88 says:

    click on one of the sites below to get a variety of the best tips and tricks in life. paito warna china

  8. Lala Kala says:

    Today I’m going to share with you the Complete Douchebag Workout 2 Cheats list (100% Working).

    If you’re sick to death of people near you, don’t think much about it. Pack your bags and join the gymnasium to become stronger as well as popular. This funny game on bodybuilding makes you the coolest guy in the town after completing a few exercises.

  9. budgetbuyer says:

    Are You Looking For Best Toothpaste Then Click On The Link To Visit This Site Here You Will Find Best 10 Toothpaste To Shining Your Teeth.

  10. pakir eam says:

    H Beams are commonly used in the construction of buildings as well but also large trailers and bridges, among others.

  11. RMTAP says:

    Online courses after training must necessarily be with live communication and discussion of issues and what they have learned.
    Risk management theory and practice

  12. Larry Walters says:

    I found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research … It’s a good post .. keep posting and updating information.
    Automotive Locksmith Waldorf MD

  13. Roy faron says:

    I really impressed after read this because of some quality work and informative thoughts . I just wanna say thanks for the writer and wish you all the best for coming!.
    Vehicle Lockout Waldorf MD

  14. Civil Lead says:

    Great info, thanks for sharing it. Building Estimate

  15. Civil Lead says:

    Amazing post, thank you for sharing this knowledgeable post, really this is very helpful.

  16. kalvinjohn says:

    These are some great tools that i definitely use for SEO work. This is a great list to use in the future…
    Stage Lighting Services in Land O’ Lakes Fl.

  17. oscar says:

    Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading.
    commercial moving services in Fairfax VA

  18. Rosie says:

    Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.
    Moving Services in Fairfax VA

  19. clinica de recuperação says:

    Clínica de Recuperação clinica de reabilitação com elevado padrão de qualidade no tratamento da dependência química, alcoolismo, recuperação de dependentes quimicos e alcoolatras.
    clinica de recuperação

  20. clinica de recuperação says:

    Tratamento Alcoolismo

  21. clinica de recuperação says:

    Internação involuntária

  22. clinica de recuperação says:

    Internação Voluntária

  23. clinica de recuperação says:

    Internação Compulsória

  24. clinica de recuperação says:

    Internação de alcoólatras

  25. suiko says:

    Thanks for your helpful information. I have been struggling to find many questions about this issue. I will follow you! moto x3m

  26. William says:

    Learn about Construction, working, least count and how to read a Micrometer Screw Gauge and get a FREE PDF on it.

  27. Juana Mathews says:

    A comprehensive comparison between the top Free SMTP servers and how to set them up to take advantage of the Free emails using SMTP.

  28. clair filip says:

    That is the excellent mindset, nonetheless is just not help to make every sence whatsoever preaching about that mather. Virtually any method many thanks in addition to i had endeavor to promote your own article in to delicius nevertheless it is apparently a dilemma using your information sites can you please recheck the idea. thanks once more.
    Dryer Vent Cleaning Severna Park MD

  29. igfontsgenerators says:

    you can easily create instagram fonts with us

  30. Linda Ween says:

    Hello. Have you ever used the service https://bestwritingservice.com/affiliate-program.html The company has a great affiliate program. You can get 10% off the order if you use a referral link. To my mind, it is a golden opportunite to save money.

  31. mylonestar says:

    Need an embroidery digitizer at a cheap price, we are here for you.digiembroidey provides the best quality embroidery digitizing at a cheap price par stich. mylonestar

  32. Leading Digital Marketing Services Company in New Jersey says:

    We, CMT Direct, can help you get more LEADS, traffic, and revenue with the right strategy.
    In addition, we are a Leading Digital Marketing Services Company in New Jersey.

  33. just meme says:

    looking for best meme checkout best webste memes-generator.net

  34. melania77 says:

    However, user-centred design is not enough for gamification. … That said, why not go retro for a moment and see what these games have … Let’s kick off this topic by remembering that in any game, a fair … The Ultimate Guide to Visual Perception and Design … Monitoring Player Motivation for Gamification.

Skip to toolbar